Our HOA held its annual meeting yesterday, Tuesday, November 10th, at the Lone Tree Hub, and this year we reached quorum. Here’s a recap of what was discussed about dues, events, reserves, insurance, enforcement, and an opening on the board.
Dues are going to $216, not $220
Last month, we shared that the board approved raising dues from $180 to $220 a year. At the annual meeting, the HOA president explained that after the board approved $220, it was brought to his attention that our HOA’s Declaration limits how much dues can increase.
Section 9.12 of the Declaration says the board can’t raise the annual assessment to more than 120% of the prior year’s amount, unless members representing at least two-thirds of all votes in our HOA approve it. With dues at $180, that limit is $216.
A revised budget at $216 was presented at the meeting. It was not the budget mailed to owners ahead of time. Starting in January, it looks like our dues will go from $180 to $216 a year.
The revised budget keeps the events budget at $80,000 and projects a loss of about $2,300 for 2027.
Events: well over budget, with no approval process described
Events got the most discussion. Neighbors said they love our events and thanked the volunteers who run them. Our HOA planned 14 events this year, with nine different volunteers leading them. The spring event drew about 200 people.
The concern was how the events budget is managed.
Total events: budgeted at $60,000 this year, and on track to cost over $83,000.
Spring event: budgeted at $3,000, and cost about $12,000. That’s four times its budget.
Fall family photos: budgeted at $18,000, and cost around $22,600.

Residents asked how spending over budget gets approved. The board did not describe an approval process. Board members said that without registration, it’s hard to predict attendance.
Residents pointed out that the board already handled this well for one item: the spring event bought flowers for 100 people, and when they were gone, they were gone. Residents suggested that every expense should work that way, with costs set in advance, so a bigger crowd doesn’t make an event cost two, three, or four times its budget.
Residents also suggested forming a committee of residents to help decide which events to hold and what they should cost. The board was open to the idea.
Reserves: nearly $370,000, and one asset
Our HOA has nearly $370,000 in reserves. The only property our HOA owns is the monument sign at Lincoln and Yosemite.
A reserve study is a report that estimates what an HOA will need to repair or replace over time, and how much it should have saved to cover those costs. Here’s what our HOA’s 2019 reserve study found:
It recommended a reserve balance of $1,750. At the time, our HOA had $366,153, which meant we were more than 20,000% funded.
The only major expense it projected over 30 years was replacing the monument sign in 2047, at about $38,900.
It rated our risk of a special assessment as low every year for 30 years, without our HOA adding a single dollar to reserves.

For the past couple of years, the board said our reserves were more than we needed, and it spent them down on purpose. At this meeting, the HOA president described the reserves differently: as a cushion in case our HOA is pulled into a lawsuit.
The board’s presentation said Keystone reviewed the 2019 study in July and confirmed it is accurate. During the meeting, the president said he had never seen the reserve study.
The board committed to a new reserve study and to developing a reserve policy. Keep in mind that a reserve study looks at what an HOA owns and will need to repair or replace. It doesn’t measure lawsuit risk. That’s what insurance is for.
Insurance: the umbrella policy the board declined
If the reason for keeping hundreds of thousands in reserve is lawsuit risk, then how our HOA insures against that risk matters.
Our HOA’s policy renewed at about $5,200, down from about $8,200 last year. The board kept workers’ comp but declined an umbrella policy, which would have cost about $4,000. An umbrella policy adds liability coverage above the limits of a base policy.
When residents asked why, the president said the main reason was that an umbrella policy makes our HOA a bigger target, and that the $4,000 didn’t feel necessary.
Residents disagreed. They said lawsuits generally go after whatever coverage is available, so an umbrella is a cost-effective way to protect our HOA. Without one, they said, a lawsuit could go after our reserves instead. One resident compared the $4,000 umbrella policy to the roughly $12,000 spent on a single event.
The president also said our HOA is named as an additional insured on the Metro District’s insurance. When asked whether that means two policies would cover a claim against our HOA, he said it depends, and his explanation of the coverage changed over the course of the meeting.
A resident also asked about land that county records still list under our HOA’s name. The president said that land was transferred to the Metro District under a long-term lease years ago, and that the sign is the only thing our HOA owns.
How this generally works. We’re not lawyers, but our understanding is that insurance pays to defend our HOA in a lawsuit, even one without merit, and pays a judgment up to the policy’s limit. Reserves don’t defend anything. Cash in the bank is simply money a judgment can be paid from. And being an additional insured on another organization’s policy typically covers claims tied to that organization’s operations, not our HOA’s own.
Several residents urged the board to buy its own umbrella policy. The board said it will revisit insurance and the umbrella with its carrier and the Metro District to get clarity.
Enforcement
Keystone still inspects the neighborhood monthly, along with the board’s larger spring and fall walkthroughs. The board said it chose not to be strict on landscaping this year because of water restrictions.
If you see a violation, report it to Nicole Sanchez, our HOA’s manager at Keystone, not to the Metro District.
Board election and an open seat
Two board members were reelected to three-year terms, and the third seat is still open. The board is looking for someone with a financial background who could eventually step into the treasurer role, and plans to email the neighborhood about it. A former treasurer shared that the role is not a big time commitment.
If you think you could fill this role, please consider it. You’ll find the HOA board member application here.
What’s next
The HOA board is not meeting in December. Its next meeting is expected in January. Metro District updates will be shared in a separate post.
A big thank you to everyone who came, asked questions, and spoke up, and to the neighbors who volunteer their time on our board and at our events.
Thanks, friends!